China and colour revolutions also published @ The Financial Express
The term “colour revolution” has its roots in protests that toppled unpopular regimes in former Soviet states and the Middle East since early this century. Colour revolutions are street level uprisings which have led to regime change in supposedly democratic but actually authoritarian states. They are called colour revolutions because protesters wore a particular colour in the protests.
By Lt Gen P R Shankar (R)
It seemed out of place when Xi Jinping spoke of ‘colour revolutions’ instigated by ‘external forces’ during the SCO meet. He asked member states to maintain strategic independence and safeguard regional stability. He also said ”We should guard against attempts by external forces to instigate colour revolutions, jointly oppose interference in other countries' internal affairs under any pretext, and hold our future firmly in our own hands".
A couple of days later, China’s Public Security Minister Wang Xiahong urged security forces to uphold stability ahead of the National Party Congress in an article of a major communist party journal. He warned law enforcement to stay alert to the risk of “colour revolution” ahead of National Party Congress next month. He stressed on the importance of loyalty to President Xi Jinping and the leadership. He urged law enforcement agencies to “clear risks” and “maintain stability” , “prevent political security risks first” “coordinate efforts within and outside the country, online and offline, and carry out in-depth anti-infiltration, anti-subversion, anti-terrorist and anti-secession struggles to vigorously safeguard the security of state power, institutions and ideology”.
Very interesting indeed. It cannot be a coincidence that Xi Jinping speaks of something one day in an international conference and two days later his Public Security Minister speaks of internal threats in the same vein. The issue is this. Is a colour revolution on the cards in China or is a purge on the cards in the name of colour revolution? Needs some thought.
What is a colour revolution? The term ‘colour revolution’ has root in protests that toppled unpopular regimes in former Soviet states and the Middle East since early this century. Colour revolutions are street level uprisings which have led to regime change in supposedly democratic but actually authoritarian states. They are called colour revolutions because protesters wore a particular colour in the protests. For instance, in Ukraine it was an Orange Revolution. It was the Rose revolution in Georgia and the Cedar revolution in Lebanon. They have also been named after flowers as in the Tulip Revolution of Kyrgyzstan and the Jasmine Revolution of Tunisia. The Arab Spring which was a series of anti-government protests, uprisings and armed rebellions across much of the Arab World( Libya, Egypt, Syria, Yemen and Bahrain) in the early 2010s are also referred to as colour revolutions. China considers the Hong Kong protests of 2019 as part of the ‘colour revolution’ creed.
Xi's statement indicated a Chinese apprehension and anxiety that the West and in particular USA could stoke pro-democracy and human rights activists in China to undermine his rule. To a large extent the situation in China is ripe for a colour revolution. Zero covid has brought misery to people’s daily lives. Lockdowns and the repression which goes with it has wrecked livelihood and the economies of people at large. The Shanghai lock down brought out the worst of China’s zero covid policy and crashed Xi’s ‘victory over Covid’ declaration to the ground. It highlighted the lengths which the CCP was prepared to go to shore up its incompetence. It exposed China’s hollow boasts about its useless vaccines. After that lockdown many other cities have gone in to lockdown and Chinese people have suffered at large and are continuing to do so. Chengdu went into a lockdown on 01 Sep. It is just about coming out of lock down. However not much news has filtered out. That’s because the only thing which seems to have improved in this period is the reprehensive Chinese censorship apparatus. My Pet Chinese Monkey claims that the Chinese have universally high IQ…much higher than Indians. If that be so, the high IQ Chinese people would have realised that Xi Jinping has rendered them all defenceless and put them at risk of widespread disease/death due to Covid because of useless vaccines. Alternately he has put them all at economic ruin and loss of livelihood through extensive lockdowns. If I were one of the high IQ Chinese people, I would show two fingers to XI Jinping and join/instigate a colour revolution since I am squarely between the devil and the deep blue sea without an insurance policy. If I were XI, I would apprehend that a colour revolution is a reality.
However that is not the only reason for a colour revolution in China. The developed world has started considering China as a systemic rival. Xi’s hard left policies have converted a thriving and growing economy into a sluggish one. Export momentum has slowed and factory activity has shrunk. When multi storey buildings are brought down, common people resort to demonstration to retrieve their hard earned money from banks, when borrowers en-mass refuse to pay up mortgages, when there is constant food hoarding in house holds due to impending lockdowns, when the sick and aged are denied treatment due to movement restrictions, when expats start leaving the country, when fatal crashes occur due to Covid controls and when youth feel despair due to lack of jobs/opportunities and feel that that they are in a ‘helpless mood’ and ‘everything is unknown’….a colour revolution is on the cards. On top of it , the UN says that there are humanitarian crimes being committed by the state and about a million are under illegal detention in re-education centres. All this is compounded by earthquakes, a severe drought and typhoons which forbodes a catastrophe descending on China due to Climate Change. The response to all this is debt fuelled infrastructure which is at best risky but downright foolish. At the core, the social contract between the 1.4 billion people and the Communist Party of giving prosperity and security(s) to people in return for their freedom is frayed. Under such repressed conditions, one does not need USA or any outside force to instigate colour revolutions. All one has to do is look in the mirror if you are a Chinese ruler and the answer will stare at your face.
However it needs different look also. Off late there have been many top officials expelled from the Communist Party. Some have been executed . The reasons attributed to such extreme punishments have been corruption, immorality and extremely distorted view of power of these officials. However when one zooms out in time and space, to see the larger picture, it pops out that nearly 5 million ‘members’ have been caught in Xi’s and Communist Party’s anti-corruption drive over the past decade. This is not an anti-corruption drive but a ‘ruthless and relentless ideological campaign aimed at consolidating power by crushing political rivals and strengthening control over all levels of society’ as per a SCMP report. In common parlance it is called a ‘Purge’ normally associated with authoritarian regimes and definitely with Communist ones.
In these conditions, if Xi is aiming to further solidify his power by securing an unprecedented third term and anoint himself as leader for life; he is depriving many aspirants for his post! There will be political opposition from many future Xi Jinping’s. They have to be uprooted through a leadership shake-up . In a society which drips with corruption, there is a limit to which ‘corruption’ can be used as an excuse for a purge. Overuse of ‘corruption’ as a cause belli for a purge might end up as a cause celebre to instigate a colour revolution in a situation where China is ripe for a ‘colour revolution’ otherwise. Hence when the Public Security Minister exhorts security agencies to focus on preventing and resisting ‘colour revolutions’ it makes a lot of sense. He is using ‘colour revolution’ to start a purge to prevent a ‘Colour Revolution’ so that Xi Jinping becomes the uncrowned king for life. Xi Jinping is pointing his finger at USA and the West, but is actually pointing a gun at his opponents head! What do you call this? The game of Chinese Thrones?
As an Indian and a concerned citizen of this world I view it differently. Malevolent Chinese machinations, when conflated with the perceived colour revolution tells me something else. If there is a ‘colour revolution’ in China – whatever the reason – a decline is imminent. If Xi Jinping purges his opposition, and becomes the uncontested king without any semblance of an opposition, he will hasten the decline which has already set in. If there is no purge Xi Jinping will be a king constantly under threat from the unpurged opposition and the spectre of a ‘colour revolution’ will always colour the horizon. In that case he will weaken China further. Whichever way it goes, the colour revolution imaginary, real or contrived is all set to take China down the slippery path.
Many who read this might contend the fact that China is declining. Well consider this. The average number of graduates who enter the job market in China has been around 10-11 million annually. In the last 3-4 years, the number of births in China has been around 10-11 million babies. The college enrolment rate is around 50% in China. In the next generation, China will either not have so many educated people or not have so many skilled people. If this is not a decline…what is? The Chinese decline is for the real and palpable…time for India and the world to look at colour revolutions, Xi Jinping, pet monkeys and high IQ Chinese people differently.
PS:- Truth stings. Don't miss the braying comment of my Chinese donkey (incidentally he has morphed from a monkey into a donkey)
Refs:-
The concern about color revolutions is centered on secession movements. There is a Canadian sponsored color revolution in the works aimed at splitting apart India. Brilliant Sikh Khalsa colors everywhere last week in Brampton, Ontario. https://twitter.com/samirsaran/status/1571732910826487810
ReplyDeleteSamir Saran joked a piece of Canada has become Khalistan. He puts on a brave face. But I doubt he is oblivious to the implication. Brampton will be the base for overthrow of the Indian state. China can help establish a Special Frontier Force for young men in Brampton who like danger.
Be careful you might be in the purgatory line Comrade!
DeleteHello Chee Chee Chinese monkey now hee hawing as a donkey! Go bray somewhere else or give us access to your Chinky Minky Hee haw donkey media! Mindless dope of a donkey
DeletePure hee haw of a gadha
DeleteComrades, please vote.
ReplyDeleteShould Indian Governed Punjab Be an Independent Country?
YES ☐
NO ☐
The compulsions of geography cannot be overcome, that is, it can't survive as an independent country. Just look at the state of affairs across the border. Please don't bring up these absurd propositions.
DeleteKhalistan is landlocked. However, after independence, Khalistan can join the Belt and Road. Chinese connectivity projects would link the new country by rail and roads to the ports of Gwadar and Karachi. Are there other problems of geography?
DeleteThey will get the belt and be run over on the road. It will be a country held together by the most regressive abrahamic version of the glorious dharmic traditions of the Gurus and will as such will also regress towards some idealized past, much as Pakistan and Afghanistan. The hostility of an overwhelmingly larger islamist population on their western borders will never allow them the kind of free access they would need to the ports. For that matter, Pak Punjab is itself land-locked and it's more than likely it will lose control over the regions that make it even minimally viable.
DeleteEven if one sets all this aside, the geographical compulsions are the super large markets and economic ties to the rest of India. Anyone willing to forego access to this is unlikely to run a prosperous country. But then, the Khalistani movement is a drug/crime cartel grab for territory and can't be accused of rational thinking being their strong point.
Anyways, the original Khalistan terrorism was sorted out by the good people of Punjab themselves and will be sorted out again by them in the unlikely event of Pakistan getting much traction in re-stoking the fires.
Pakistan and Khalistan would both face a hostile India. They would work together. Khalistan would be assured ocean access by Pakistan.
DeleteThe Punjabi economy is not doing well. In FY 2019-20, GDP per capita of Punjab was $2,164, barely above the national average. The benefits of union are not evident in economic performance. In fact, the union imposes a burden. The suffering Khalsa farmer is not allowed to burn stubble at the insistence of priviliged Delhiites. He must in September harvest the paddy crop and then in 3 weeks, without any respite, sow the wheat crop. I think it would be rational for the farmers of Punjab to reject India.
Ah, victimhood card at full play I see. Please go back to even the recent history of Punjab to understand all the TLC showered upon the sikhs & hindus by the islamists. What percentage of sikhs have survived in your beloved Pakistan ?Heck, just look at Afghanistan this year alone. You guys do live in some la-la land of being united by some common and unjustified hatred. The Khalsa farmer is not suffering, he's living an unsustainable subsidized existence which is destroying the very land he depends on with its economic mal-incentives. Any rational economic plan to fix this is opposed blindly due to a blind hatred of a "hindu" party which ironically has been a staunch supporter of the common sikh. Greater India is full of opportunities for any rational community. Don't be dragged down to the level (and worse) of Pakistan by a "cut off one's nose to spite one's face" attitude.
DeleteNothing will happen. It's all noise. As such their main sponsor is in trouble itself and likely to break up. If it tries anything more then repercussions will be swift nad brutal. It's all a money making ploy on part of khalistani supporters nad organisations.
DeleteHowever Canada may end u becoming kanedda for good
Sir, color revolutions are also a way for globalist/hostile powers to overthrow even democratically elected governments. The Ukrainian color revolution being a case in point where the US State Dept (Victoria Nuland and co) and the CIA engineered a violent uprising to get rid of the Yanukovich regime. I would instead hope for a peaceful and enlightened transition of Chinese society. They have/had exemplars in Taiwan and Hong Kong to show the path towards a prosperous and well adjusted society. Unfortunately this is unlikely to happen as long as the CCP is calling the shots. Much like Pakistan is an "army with a country," China is a "party with a country." Neither is going to be willing to let go of power voluntarily.
ReplyDeleteWhy has the General demoted me? Is it because the Khalistan movement growing in strength is implausible? I think not. I must have hit a nerve.
ReplyDeleteAnother idiot or perhaps the same who thinks the General wastes his time responding to comments here. Hey, "empty"stani, those were readers observations not the Generals.
DeletePS:- Truth stings. Don't miss the braying comment of my Chinese donkey (incidentally he has morphed from a monkey into a donkey)
DeleteGreat job Sir,
DeleteBilkul aag lagaa di aapne. Now I expect more and more monkeys to descend and attempt to feast simply to drown out your voice.
Hang in there and keep going. WE Indians enjoy reading your posts and learn a lot, one heck of a lot. :-) Aapne rukna nahin hai Sir, likhte rahiye.
Another Indian sycophant reading and commenting with banal encouragement is of no use to the General. If you want to see a monkey, wait for that gonads guy ("Xi Jingballs hehe") to show up. I respond to the General with thoughtful comments filled with hard data and clear lines of thinking. The General should thank me for training him up and making him a tougher, more intellectual thinker.
DeleteIf you had the b@lls, to lecture the esteemed Lt Gen, show us your nuts ( or peanuts) by identifying youself! Maa ka dudh piya hai ya, gadhe ka dudh pee ke yahah bhadve ke jaise likh raha hai?
DeleteHAHAHAHA just love it.
DeleteDid I tell you about that knife we carry around? Pretty handy in cutting off those 11 Jingballs. We can chop 'em, fry'em and send them off to your little emperors at Pangong tso for lunch...
Just in case you didn't know, they're called Khukris...
:) and the chinkies will eat anything, even Jingpingpongs b@lls!
Delete:-D Interesting situation. Looks like 11 Jingballs has been CUT!!! AND consumed in china itself.
DeleteWe didn't need to do anything. Bandar - tell your interrrested audience how they tasted or were yours also offered up...
And while you are about it, try frying it with ginger, though you might not recognize the taste...
Delete