Skip to main content

CHINA TANG PING :A DISCUSSION

In the forthcoming week there will be lot of focus on the 20th Party congress. It is an important event from many perspectives and also a non event since the outcomes will not hold many surprises. However, there is also a social factor in the evolving dynamics of China. That barely gets noticed. The future of any nation are its youth. The youth in China are quite disillusioned. The indications are on the wall. This is counter to the grandstanding which will be on display during the High Profile 20 Party Congress. In this discussion, Aadi and I delve into this aspect. The discussion is different but will be significant in times to come. 


 

Comments

  1. Sir, very interesting discussion as usual. Thinking about the compulsions of demography, it seems to me that the Chinese expansion into Tibet was perhaps inevitably driven by their exploding population and the intersection of the need to keep this population occupied and the availability of ultra-cheap human resource to fuel an expanded lebensraum. Now that this trend has reversed and decelerating ever quicker, would it change the Chinese outlook to shrinking the lebensraum to the core Han areas? Perhaps by the end of the decade they would be amenable to any agreement that would give them a face saving exit out of the economic and human burden of sustaining such a physically inhospitable region.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good point. Building on this:
      a. we know that an aging population is less expansive, less aggressive. So China's current aggressive avatar will tone down with time. The questions are how do we hang on till then and leverage this appropriately.
      b. It seems they are trying to encourage immigration (looks like the target is Africa, India). But China is not very rich, is a very insular economy and immigrants are usually not welcome (they will especially not be welcome when China goes through it's inevitable downturn) as they are NOT Han Chinese. So either they will NOT get enough immigrants (most likely situation - like Japan) or they'll get the worst of the lot (Pakistan etc.,). If that happens, they will be ingesting (radicalism) poison, making things worse and making immigrants even more unwelcome...

      All in all, China will most probably go through a very bad century - unless something really unexpected happens.

      Your thoughts on this, Sir.

      Delete
    2. It is high time that China worries about the way their youth are growing in a Negative environment. They should stop the expansionist policy,and concentrate their energy inward to do better man-management.Even young do not want to be in Armed Forces, and are forced into it, hence lacks motivation . Adv( Col) AshokLeekha

      Delete
    3. "The Lebensraum" of Retzel was not
      only about the living space for the population of a nation It was mainly
      about natural resources and strategic
      advantages that space provided.
      Germany had enough space to live
      for its own population but Hitler took
      the risk of opening a second front
      against Russia despite Bismark s
      advice a generation earlier.It was
      mainly for the resource rich Caspian
      region.
      China is not going to give up Tibet
      or any of the outer regions that it
      has conquered even if it's population
      is reduced
      to half the present population level

      Delete
    4. Let's take a longer perspective on this (thinking about Shelley's poem: Ozymandias). So many Empires have come and gone. They work they did, the statues they put up are all dust. In Europe: The Roman, the British, the French, the Turks, the Greeks etc., etc., Even India: So many empires who once spread from Persia to Japan: The Cholas, Guptas, etc., etc., are gone...

      I would expect the same thing about China, US, EU etc., The only question is when. In such a case, I can't see China hold on to Tibet... Then the question is: How do we make them losen their control quicker...

      Delete
    5. Further building on my comment above. The "History and the decline of the Roman Empire" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_History_of_the_Decline_and_Fall_of_the_Roman_Empire is instructive (I reall wish we had a similar level of detail captured for the Cholas, Mauryas, Guptas etc.,).

      Crudely paraphrasing: once the Roman Empire went into "decline", the Barbarians first nibbled at the edges and then advanced into the heart...

      Soooo... Why wouldn't (gasp) the "Indian Barbarian" nibble at the edges of the Tibetian plateau and then advance into the heart over the decades as Pooh's empire gently declines and falls? How do we do this?

      Delete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

THE POST BALAKOT REVIEW BY LT GEN P R SHANKAR (R)

The Pakistani FM to BBC: War would be suicidal. Pakistan has already started negotiating with a gun to its head! Welcome home Wing Commander Abhinanadan. Well done. You flew into the Valley of Death and survived.  India is proud. Sincere condolences to Air Marshal Waseem Ud Din on the loss of his son Shahaz Ud Din under most unfortunate circumstances. He was incredibly brave to continue his mission when others had turned around.   Paradigm Emerged A lot has happened since Balakot. Some in focus some out. Some hyped. Some diffused. Time to sum up the situation and see where things are heading. Militarily it is called Review of the Situation. I will do it journalistically so that the intellectual western media understands it. They might or not buy our story. Incidentally it is not a story. It is not for sale. This is real live action. Nuclear exchange receding. Not ruled out.     A fundamental paradigm has emerged. India’s fight is ag...

Don’t Burn the Last Bastion by Lt Gen P R Shankar (R)

‘Sir, will China invade us?’  ‘We hear China has increased activities on the border’. Chinese consolidation activities on the LAC have prompted such reactions and fears. Lot of such inquiries from citizens within and outside India. Why?  Bodies floating down Ganga, mass graves, lack of oxygen, medicines or hospital beds, botched vaccination program, uninterrupted work on Central Vista - all these have eroded our political capital immensely and seeded such doubts. Our national institutions are being compared to ‘rottweilers’ in the media. Economy? Unemployment figures and stock markets – both rattling up. Strangest combination. Rich getting richer and poor getting poorer. An ominous divergence which bodes ill. Leadership? Kis Chidiya ka naam hai bhai? National level paralysis in responding to the second wave. Erosion in comprehensive national power.  Many have never experienced India being so weak. Nor did I for that matter. This frightening experience ...

GUNNERS SHOT HITS THE MILLION MARK

IT GIVES ME A GREAT SENSE OF PRIDE THAT ' GUNNERS SHOT ' HAS HAD ITS  'MILLIONTH VIEWER'  TODAY MORNING.  PLEASE SEE THE TABLE BELOW.                                 I STARTED THE BLOG IN MARCH 2019 WHEN SOME OF MY ARTICLES WERE REJECTED BY NATIONAL MEDIA AND REPUTED PLATFORMS. THEY PROBABLY FELT THAT MY  ARTICLES DO NOT DESERVE  SPACE IN THEIR PUBLICATIONS. HOWEVER I THANK THEM FOR NUDGING ME TO STRIKE OUT ON MY OWN.     SO I SET MY OWN STANDARDS.    I ALSO COULD NOT COMPROMISE IN PUTTING ACROSS MY VIEW POINT THE WAY I FELT IT WAS NECESSARY FOR EVERYONE TO KNOW. I CHOSE TO BE UNBIASED AND EXPRESS WHAT IS GOOD FOR INDIA WITHOUT ANY COLOURING.  I HAVE ALSO FELT THAT IT IS IMPORTANT FOR EVERY INDIAN TO KNOW WHAT IS RELEVANT FOR OUR SECURITY IN AS SIMPLE TERMS AS POSSIBLE. IT IS ONLY THEN THAT HE WILL BE ABLE TO APPRECIATE AND SUPPORT THE ARMED FORCE...